Back to press
Prevous
Next
This is some text inside of a div block.

THIS BULL MARKET ISN'T AS BIG AS YOU THINK

https://www.wsj.com/articles/this-bull-market-isnt-as-big-as-you-think-11591365601

This Bull Market Isn’t as Big as You Think

Just a few big winners are responsible for most of the stock market’s rapid recovery

By Jason Zweig

June 5, 2020 10:00 am ET

‍

The gap between Wall Street and Main Street has never seemed wider—but much of it is an illusion.

Since it bottomed on March 23, the S&P 500 has shot up almost 40%—the highest return over so short a period since 1933, according to S&P Dow Jones Indices. For the year-to-date, the S&P 500 is down less than 3%, counting dividends. Meanwhile,108,000 Americans have died in a pandemic, 21 million are out of work and the country is seething with civil unrest.

This disconnect isn’t as extreme as it seems. Beneath the surface, much of the stock market is suffering, too. Most stocks are down this year, many by 20% or more. A few fortunate winners have generated big gains, fueling the misperception that losses have been minimal. The result is a market that isn’t as irrationally exuberant as it might appear.

U.S. stocks as a whole are far from cheap by historical standards, but the market isn’t blind to the calamities that surround us.

Yes, for the year to date, Zoom Video Communications Inc. ZM -1.31% is up 209%, Regeneron Pharmaceuticals Inc. 59% and Amazon.com Inc. 33%. But entire industries have been flattened: Earlier this week, airlines were down an average of 52% year to date; banks, 33%; energy, 32%; autos, 30%; consumer finance, 27%. Even utilities were down 5%.

Overall, of the 3,470 stocks in the Wilshire 5000 index that traded between Dec. 31, 2019, and June 2, 73% had negative returns for the year to date.

It isn’t unusual for the stock market to split into a few extreme winners and lots of losers. In 1973, a few darlings rose to near-record valuations while most stocks fell miserably. In 1999, technology shares shot up more than 80% even as many companies in the broader market languished and Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway Inc. fell 20%.

Seldom, however, has the gap between the haves and the have-nots been as wide as it is now.

In the first five months of this year, big growth stocks rose 6.1% while small, low-priced “value” stocks lost 25.6%. That was the biggest gap in performance between them over any such period since early 1999 and the second widest on record back to 1986, according to AJO, a Philadelphia-based investment firm.

Haves vs. Have-Nots

Despite the pandemic, massive unemployment and growing social unrest, U.S. stocks are down only a few percentage points in 2020. This helps mask wide return disparities.

The 50 most-expensive stocks in the S&P 500 as of last Dec. 31 were up an average of 11.3% through June 3, according to Drew Dickson, chief investment officer at London-based Albert Bridge Capital LLP. The 50 cheapest stocks, meanwhile, were down an average of 16.8%.

“People want to pay even more than they did for the stocks they already loved, and even less for the stocks that they didn’t,” says Mr. Dickson. “There’s no reason why that should be the case, other than a very fearful market thinking that big, expensive, high-quality companies must be safer at any price.”

Already out of favor going into 2020, small and value stocks suffered further as investors fled to perceived safety amid the pandemic and economic lockdown.

In recent days, small and value stocks have begun to show signs of recovery as the biggest, hottest stocks have flagged.

After all, when large growth stocks are “priced to perfection, they have to deliver on that just to maintain their valuation,” warns Nili Gilbert, co-founder and portfolio manager at Matarin Capital Management LLC in New York.

Such hot stocks as Amazon, Advanced Micro Devices Inc., Netflix Inc. and Salesforce.com Inc. are all trading for more than 50 times their anticipated earnings for 2020, according to FactSet.

“Maybe now, as the market believes that we’re going to be able to recover, some of those heavier industries, like cyclicals, materials and industrials, will lead the charge,” says Ms. Gilbert. “The expectations [for small stocks and value stocks] have gotten so low that that’s become a catalyst in itself.”

You could see a perfect example of that on Thursday, when shares in American Airlines Group Inc. soared more than 40% on news that the carrier would restore more flights to its schedule. Some battered stocks in such industries as hotels and recreation have already been bouncing back so sharply that investors should be cautious.

None of this means the dominance of growth stocks is definitively ending even as we speak. If you had a dollar for every time in the past decade a value-stock portfolio manager predicted value stocks were about to recover, you would be waist-deep in cash right now.

Yet it stands to reason that, in the long run, cheaper stocks will outperform more-expensive ones. Decades—even centuries—of history suggest that value should excel in the end, although the wait can be long.

Patient investors can overweight value stocks in their portfolios on the reasonable assumption that their underperformance can’t last indefinitely. And all investors should recognize that, while some shares are booming, the market as a whole isn’t as oblivious to economic hardship as it might seem.

Write to Jason Zweig at intelligentinvestor@wsj.com

You might Also Like

OK, 2022 WAS A DISASTER FOR TESLA. WHAT NEXT?

Read more

FAULT LINES IN US AND EUROPEAN EQUITIES AND BEHAVIORAL FINANCE

A discussion between Drew Dickson of Albert Bridge Capital and Morgan Housel of The Collaborative Fund; moderated by Jamie Catherwood of O'Shaughnessy Asset Management.
Read more

ON BEHAVIORAL FINANCE AND STOCK PICKING

Drew chats with Dr. Daniel Crosby about behavioral economics and stock-picking.
Read more

WHY EUROPEAN VALUE STOCKS MIGHT WIN

In a return to normalcy, Europe might have a lot of catching up to do – particularly some of the value stocks across the continent. For American investors that have previously been shunning European opportunities, this is something worth considering.
Read more
Navigations
HomeTeamDrew's viewsPressContact
Disclaimers
Legal & regulatoryPrivacy policyCookies policy
How to get in Touch
info@albertbridgecapital.com

Subscribe to Drew's Views

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
© Albert Bridge Capital 2022
Website by SW10media.com
homeTeamdrew's viewspressCOntactDisclaimers
OK, 2022 WAS A DISASTER FOR TESLA. WHAT NEXT?
FAULT LINES IN US AND EUROPEAN EQUITIES AND BEHAVIORAL FINANCE
ON BEHAVIORAL FINANCE AND STOCK PICKING
WHY EUROPEAN VALUE STOCKS MIGHT WIN
EUROPE'S COMPANIES LANGUISH IN THE SLOW LANE
BEHAVIORAL FINANCE AND VALUE INVESTING IN EUROPE
BEHAVIORAL INVESTING AND THE INTERSECTION WITH SPORTS
THE ‘TESLA-FINANCIAL COMPLEX’
HERE'S THE MATH FOR TESLA'S STOCK PRICE IF IT BECOMES THE APPLE OF CAR MAKERS
YOU NEEDN'T HOLD YOUR STOCK WINNERS
BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS' LATEST BIAS
AA’s BIGGEST SHAREHOLDER REJECTS 'DERISORY' OFFER
AA’s BIGGEST SHAREHOLDER SETS UP ROADBLOCK TO BUY-OUT WITH OBJECTION TO "DERISORY' OFFER
AA TAKEOVER TALKS TRIGGER SHAREHOLDER BREAKDOWN
STALLING AA CALLS FOR RESCUE OF ITS OWN
THERE'S SUCH A THING AS TOO MANY MEETINGS WITH THE CEO
VALUE STOCK INVESTORS HOPE VACCINE BOOST CAN LAST
BAILLIE GIFFORD'S NEVER-SELL MANTRA IS A SONG FOR FOOLS
FINDING ALPHA THROUGH BEHAVIOURAL INVESTING IN EUROPE
I'VE PULLED OUT ALL THE STOPS FOR TESLA, BUT CAN'T FIND UPSIDE.
THIS BULL MARKET ISN'T AS BIG AS YOU THINK
BLENDING BEHAVIOUR & FUNDAMENTALS AT ALBERT BRIDGE CAPITAL
INMARSAT BUYOUT FACES FRESH OPPOSITION AS COURT RULING LOOMS
BUBBLE ECONOMICS: THE ACTIVE VS. PASSIVE DEBATE
SHORT SELLERS "SHOULD BE KNIGHTED, NOT SPITED"
FINANCIAL TWITTER LOSES A SOURCE OF HUMILITY AND WISDOM, BUT GOOD VOICES REMAIN
THE FUTILITY OF MARKET TIMING
ALBERT BRIDGE BORDERS ON ‘SUGGESTIVISM’ IN BACKING MICRO FOCUS RECOVERY - PROFILER
ALBERT BRIDGE’S DREW DICKSON AT IRA SOHN
VOLKSWAGEN STOCK IS CHEAP AND HAS LOTS OF HORSEPOWER
THE DAY VOLKSWAGEN BRIEFLY CONQUERED THE WORLD
A CHALLENGE TO THE BIGGEST IDEA IN BEHAVIOURAL FINANCE
ALBERT BRIDGE CAPITAL’S DICKSON DISCUSSES NOBEL PRIZE WINNER RICHARD THALER
ALBERT BRIDGE CAPITAL'S DICKSON INCLUDED IN THE HEDGE FUND JOURNAL TOMORROW'S TITANS 2016
ALBERT BRIDGE HIRES FORMER BAML’S KENNY FOR MARKETING
ALBERT BRIDGE HIRES BAML CAP INTRO HEAD
EX-FORTRESS AND MORGAN STANLEY HEAVYWEIGHT JOINS HEDGE FUND STARTUP
EX-PERELLA WEINBERG MANAGER RAISES $150M FOR STARTUP
FORMER PERELLA WEINBERG PARTNERS EXEC DICKSON LAUNCHING NEW HEDGE FUND
EX-PERELLA WEINBERG PARTNER LAUNCHES ALBERT BRIDGE CAPITAL
EX-PERELLA WEINBERG PARTNER TO LAUNCH EQUITY HEDGE FUND